Noah Smith’s recent article on India’s rise confirms that growth (all boats rise) is more important than redistribution (welfare state), although I’m inclined to think everyone needs a little safety net now and then, and if families and networks don’t provide, who does? But those families and networks might be the greatest source of intergenerational wealth. Thomas Sowell’s massive research into cross cultural success factors surviving migration and massive upset supports the idea that economic performance is cultural (whether culture is conveyed in families generationally or classes or the habits and values of whole ethnic groups).
I'm a big fan of “widows and orphans” style charities, but I also think there comes a point in which incentives become misaligned, to the detriment of society. It's a tricky needle to thread.
Thanks! It was a lot of work to pull all the threads together without getting sidetracked by all the political implications. I just find the history of it all kinda surprising.
A few wires get crossed that don’t seem like they should when it comes to trying to make sense of class system, themselves ethereal and partially artificial. The main one is equating individual or household net worth with class. The second, related to the first in some ways, is equating the American definition and the European definition. American doesn’t have much for the great-great grandson of a guy who blew his father’s railroad millions til he drowned in red. In Britain, that guy would still get invited to the country weddings and some uncle or another would make sure he goes to Eton and no matter how much his parents owe or where he lives he’ll talk with a posh RP tone rather than estuary accent.
It's such a messy concept, unfortunately. But if I were to go back and refine my thesis, it would be something like "how much does messing with the elite actually impact their grandkids prospects?" and the answer seems to be "it depends how you go about it, but just taking their money doesn't change much about their relative status according to the proxies we can evaluate." Does that make sense?
Of course it makes sense. This is a system built on compounding irrationalisms. In the US sense, all upper class membership is defined by the parties and getaways one gets invited to, so the kingmakers are typically 1-5 hostesses for a given region. Naturally, those who don't get invited to those parties can have all the money in the world and still be left to watch from the windows. There's only so high a box that money can buy for the Kentucky Derby, every box above that level is invite-only because gates must be kept.
The Swedish lottery comparison was the most striking part for me — comparing big winners with small winners, rather than with non-players, makes the finding that life satisfaction stayed higher for over a decade while children's schooling and most other outcomes barely moved much harder to dismiss. It fits your Gray versus Ben Gunn contrast: the money helped when there was already a trade and a network to put it into, and it evaporated when there was not. I was curious about the land-reform contrast too — do you think the East Asian cases worked mainly because the recipients already knew how to farm the land, or because the credit and training structures around the transfer mattered just as much?
Noah Smith’s recent article on India’s rise confirms that growth (all boats rise) is more important than redistribution (welfare state), although I’m inclined to think everyone needs a little safety net now and then, and if families and networks don’t provide, who does? But those families and networks might be the greatest source of intergenerational wealth. Thomas Sowell’s massive research into cross cultural success factors surviving migration and massive upset supports the idea that economic performance is cultural (whether culture is conveyed in families generationally or classes or the habits and values of whole ethnic groups).
I'm a big fan of “widows and orphans” style charities, but I also think there comes a point in which incentives become misaligned, to the detriment of society. It's a tricky needle to thread.
Best essay that I’ve read in years
Aww thanks! That's high praise coming from you!
I liked this
Great article, I really enjoyed it
Thanks! It was a lot of work to pull all the threads together without getting sidetracked by all the political implications. I just find the history of it all kinda surprising.
A few wires get crossed that don’t seem like they should when it comes to trying to make sense of class system, themselves ethereal and partially artificial. The main one is equating individual or household net worth with class. The second, related to the first in some ways, is equating the American definition and the European definition. American doesn’t have much for the great-great grandson of a guy who blew his father’s railroad millions til he drowned in red. In Britain, that guy would still get invited to the country weddings and some uncle or another would make sure he goes to Eton and no matter how much his parents owe or where he lives he’ll talk with a posh RP tone rather than estuary accent.
It's such a messy concept, unfortunately. But if I were to go back and refine my thesis, it would be something like "how much does messing with the elite actually impact their grandkids prospects?" and the answer seems to be "it depends how you go about it, but just taking their money doesn't change much about their relative status according to the proxies we can evaluate." Does that make sense?
Of course it makes sense. This is a system built on compounding irrationalisms. In the US sense, all upper class membership is defined by the parties and getaways one gets invited to, so the kingmakers are typically 1-5 hostesses for a given region. Naturally, those who don't get invited to those parties can have all the money in the world and still be left to watch from the windows. There's only so high a box that money can buy for the Kentucky Derby, every box above that level is invite-only because gates must be kept.
The Swedish lottery comparison was the most striking part for me — comparing big winners with small winners, rather than with non-players, makes the finding that life satisfaction stayed higher for over a decade while children's schooling and most other outcomes barely moved much harder to dismiss. It fits your Gray versus Ben Gunn contrast: the money helped when there was already a trade and a network to put it into, and it evaporated when there was not. I was curious about the land-reform contrast too — do you think the East Asian cases worked mainly because the recipients already knew how to farm the land, or because the credit and training structures around the transfer mattered just as much?