4 Comments
User's avatar
Eric McKee's avatar

I'm thinking this is an excellent example of what peer review should look like.

Eleanor Konik's avatar

I do think there should be more emphasis on rewarding debunking and deep dives and less on "ooh a shiny novel theory"

RobRoy's avatar

Great article! Thanks for taking the time to write it

Aaron's avatar

Now I’m thinking about the legend that Vienna’s coffeehouses started with beans captured after the siege of 1683.